blogs.conchango.com

welcome to the conchango blogging site
Welcome to blogs.conchango.com Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

SSIS Junkie

MDM: An analytic solution or not?

As I get more and more embroiled in the Master Data Management (MDM) discipline I'm forming nascent opinions on what constitutes MDM, and how best to implement an MDM strategy. A common question raised about this discipline is whether your MDM system should be for supporting operational systems (e.g. running your customer-facing applications) or analytical ones (e.g. month-end reporting). My glass-half-full answer is "both".

I was involved in an internal email thread today with a bunch of colleagues when one of them asked (and I'm paraphrasing) "Do you think that MDM implementations should concentrate on modelling the real-world, or do we (as BI guys) have a much bigger focus on making the MDM dimensions mostly report ready from the outset?"

That was a very thought-provoking question. Here was my answer:

I believe its important not to pigeonhole MDM as a BI or operational technology – to do so makes a mockery of the very justification for having an MDM strategy in the first place. Let’s re-iterate what that justification is – a single view of every entity in your enterprise. If we start to get into considerations for BI when building an MDM system then you’re venturing into an MDM implementation that isn’t being done with that justification  in mind. So-called “BI” implementations should adapt to leverage MDM, not the other way around.

In an ideal world (which this is not) you wouldn’t even suck data out of your MDM application into another data silo, your reports should sit directly on top of the MDM application.  There is even a name for this reporting technique, its called federated querying (which I have mentioned in passing before here).

Sounds great in theory doesn't it? Well the best theories always do, maybe that's why they stay as theories. I am in danger of getting on my What is BI? soapbox again so I'll stop right there. Opinions are, as always, thoroughly welcomed.

-Jamie

Published 02 February 2008 00:35 by jamie.thomson

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

 

Howard @ The Hub said:

Jamie

I am one of those "Fast Living Recruitment Types" that Flynn's Blog is always talking about with such disdain.

One of the tech ones hopefully, that knows what they are talking about (all things BI)  - I suggest that you have a look at www.kalido.com if you don't know it already - its the only really stable and scalable MDM product on the market and also offers a Federated Data Warehousing solution with a lot of reference sites world wide - its the proof that its not just THEORY.........

Kind regards

Howard @ The Hub

howardL@hubrc.com

March 28, 2008 16:36
 

jamie.thomson said:

Hi Howard,

I'm sure Michelle doesn't mean any offense :)

I have heard a lot about Kalido although I have not come into direct contact with it yet. I was slightly put off when I heard that an organisation that I used to work for was considering implmenting Kalido on top a data model called PPDM that I hate with a passion - I don't see how MDM can work on anything other than a proprietary data model.

Still, I am open to being educated about this and will keep my ear to the ground regarding Kalido.

Thanks for the comment.

-Jamie

March 31, 2008 07:44

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Submit

This Blog

Syndication

News

Powered by Community Server (Personal Edition), by Telligent Systems